Solutions Elusive in Harry Wright Lake Closures

The causes of unacceptable fecal coliform levels in the lake and the resulting closures are a complex issue

Marge Camposano loves to go sit on the shore of Harry Wright Lake with her evening coffee, taking in the peace and quiet as the day winds down.

The Camden Avenue resident has frequented the lake for years, bringing her children to swim there when they were younger.

Now, she’s not so sure she’d go into the water.

“It’s such a pretty spot,” she said, but she’s worried: increasingly there have been closures of the lake to swimming due to high levels of fecal coliform bacteria in the water there.

“I’ve lived here 28 years, and up until a few years ago it was never closed,” she said.

With Pine Lake permanently closed to swimming and little hope that it will ever reopen, Camposano spoke to the Manchester Township Council on Monday night, pleading with them to take steps to try to reverse the problems now, before it becomes like Pine Lake.

“I don’t want to see that happen to Harry Wright Lake,” Camposano said.

Harry Wright Lake is one of a dozen or so freshwater lakes tested each week by the Ocean County Health Department for levels of fecal coliform, a bacteria found in the intestines of warm-blooded animals that can cause illness in humans and damage the environment, killing fish and other aquatic animals, according to www.epa.gov, the website of the Environmental Protection Agency.

The federal Safe Drinking Water Act regulates the levels of bacteria that are allowable for a body of water to be deemed safe for swimming. A fecal coliform level of 200 or more colonies per 100 milliliters of water – for a freshwater site – is deemed unacceptable, according to the Ocean County Health Department’s website.

Large quantities of fecal coliform can be harmful to the environment, killing fish and other aquatic life and also suggests the water is contaminated with bacteria that can cause disease, according to the Environmental Protection Agency's Web site.

In late July, Harry Wright Lake had unacceptable levels of fecal coliform for more than a week. The swimming ban began there on July 26, when the coliform levels exceeded 1200 colonies per 100 ml – six times the level deemed unacceptable – according to the results posted on the county’s website. It took until Aug. 3 before the levels had fallen enough for swimming to be allowed again.

The causes of the high levels seem to be multiple. A population of Canada geese can often be found around the lake, though Camposano says the number of geese appears to be fewer this year. Storm runoff has long been blamed.

And hot temperatures – like the ones that occurred the week before the coliform levels spiked in Harry Wright Lake – make the bacteria more active, said Council Vice President Brendan Weiner, who presided over Monday’s meeting in the absence of Council President Craig Wallis.

But how to address those problems is a difficult question, Weiner said. There have been discussions of trying to drain the lake during the winter months, similar to how Lacey drains Deer Head Lake, in an attempt to kill the bacteria, he said.

“We’ve been denied on them in the past,” Weiner said, with the state Department of Environmental Protection saying no.

It’s a solution that may not be having much effect in Lacey, as the bacteria numbers in Deer Head Lake this summer have far exceeded those of Harry Wright Lake and the closures have been more extensive.

Controlling the goose population has been difficult, Weiner said, noting that the geese often are simply no longer afraid. Metal silhouettes of dogs – designed to spook the geese and keep them from landing – have been removed. Weiner said the township used to pay a service to bring in dogs to scare the geese, but stopped using it when it appeared to no longer be effective.

It’s a frustrating problem, Weiner admitted, but added that Manchester is taking measures that it hops will help. New ordinances regulating how much fertilizer homeowners can use and forcing the coverage of storm drains to prevent garbage from being washed into them are a start.

He is hopeful that Gov. Chris Christie’s recent signing of a package of bills addressing water quality and making money available for stormwater runoff projects will help as well.

That, too, has been a tough road in the past, he said, because Manchester has had to fight to prove it sits in the Barnegat Bay watershed, just like its neighbors of Berkeley and Toms River.

“Convincing them (the state DEP) is really tough,” said Sabina Skibo, the township clerk.

Camposano said she realizes the problem won’t be fixed overnight.

“Just like not one thing polluted the lake, there’s not one solution (to all of it),” she said. But she wants to make sure the town doesn’t forget about it.

“I want to see them do everything possible to fix it,” she said after the meeting, then turned to Weiner. “I will keep reminding you about it.”

suz August 10, 2011 at 04:47 PM
Please don not misread my comment. I NEVER said I disagreed with you on not notifying the parents. They should have...you are the one who bashed the seniors. As for the WWII memorial, my dad was a MIA and then a POW in WWII. He suffered the rest of his life for what he went through. Do not get the vets involved!!
Billabong August 10, 2011 at 05:28 PM
Sue, I believe it is you who is misreading comments. Where exactly did I "bash" seniors? I said, and stand by my comment, that the senior community in Manchester gets preferential treatment while the issues facing PLP residents are generally ignored. Please don't lecture me on vets - many of us have a family member who was a vet (my grandfather also served in WWII) and have felt the effects of their sacrifices for the country. Since you missed the point of my original statement, I'll break it down for you: It's not that the memorial, the storm response, and the Mayor appearing at senior-laden events are wrong - it's that seniors are serviced time and again while PLP is ignored. If you lived in the park and repeatedly saw adults and children being hauled off by ambulances because of accidents at a dangerous intersection you may feel differently. If you had a lake in your backyard but couldn't use it, you wouldn't want to know why? During the election cycle, our Mayor does nothing to address our neighborhood while his opposition takes the time to go door-to-door and even answer email and return phone calls - why is that? These issues are ignored without explanation and that's simply not right.
WhitingBoy August 10, 2011 at 06:07 PM
Not just PLP...Whiting (Roosevelt City) has the highest tax rates (highest assessed homes) by far, and get zip/nada/nuttin'. It is not a senior bashing to point this out. the seniors should get the bulk of the resources (we are in a senior community, and it i sonly proper to take care of those who paved the way), but, that does not mean they get 100% of the attention and money. We pay a lot of taxes, and deserve some attention (at least the children in PLP and Whiting). The Mayor and Council do a lot to foment the “seniors against the others” mentality. I am not sure if it is intentional, but they do make all the non-seniors feel like non-entities (other than a piggy bank for the Mayor to buy senior votes).
S-MAN August 10, 2011 at 10:23 PM
Sue, I never thought Billabong was bashing seniors or veterans. He's bashing the current town administration.
Billabong August 10, 2011 at 11:54 PM
God Bless the middle class and families in Roosevelt City - I have no idea how you survive. I'm going check-to-check paying taxes on a home that could fit into the garages of many of the Roosevelt City homes. I'm with you, with the taxes you're paying, you definitely deserve some attention as well.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »